Stanley vs dewalt – Hand tools and Drill and Tape Measure Comparison

Stanley vs dewalt

There has been a seemingly a battle between industries power and hand tools bigwigs Stanley vs Dewalt. The question being, which among the two stands out in producing ergonomic, quality, and reliable tools? There are many speculations, but it is apparent that they are founded on feelings and company loyalties.

In this article we have selected tools from the same category from both companies Stanley and Dewalt to set the ring and by the end of this read; you will have taken your side based on facts and statistics. We could try and differentiate the two on industrial experience, but none of them is a newbie to the industry. Below are an outline and insight into the major factors that will set the two brands apart, or rather indicate their merit in the cases that the two brands cannot be set apart.

Stanley vs dewalt 2018

Quality and warranty comparison

The quality of the Stanley and Dewalt brands products is one that cannot face much of reprimanding, the reason being that both of the brands provide quality products in terms of materials and construction. Taking, for instance, the toolset, we will come to find out that the manufacturers have done all that is in their powers to offer quality materials. In the case that Stanley was not able to offer as good quality as Dewalt, they did so at a lesser cost, implying for a slight tradeoff between quality and cost. As for the warranties, both of the brands provide comprehensive warranties, but you need to claim the warranties by registering the products.

Reliability comparison

All the products from the two brands offer reliable performance. That is upon rationalizing one’s expectations according to the specification that the manufacturer provides. The manufacturers have put every detail of their products in black and white for everyone to see and you will not encounter hidden flaws. In general, Dewalt offers more reliable products with the Stanley product offering just as much reliability, but not quite.

Ergonomics comparison

The ergonomics are excellent in products from both companies. It is in this area that the two companies tie, owing much of it to sharing in the maturity of the two companies Stanley and Dewalt. A review through all the six products show excellent ergonomics in all of the products from lock for the tape measures, to ergonomic handle for the toolsets, to lightweight and comfortable grip handles for the hammer drills.

Maybe you will like to know:

Stanley vs dewalt hand tools

A quality tool kit set is essential for professionals and DIYers too. And Stanley and Dewalt provide the best in class toolkit sets, but one of the two stands out better than the other. STANLEY STMT73795 Mixed Tool Set, 210-Piece is made from a blow molded body, which gives strength and durability. The blow molded body allows for easy portability and transportation.

STANLEY STMT73795 Mixed Tool Set

STANLEY STMT73795 Mixed Tool Set

CHECK IT OUT

For the DeWalt DWMT73803 Mechanics Tool Kit Set with Case (168 Piece), it is made of polycarbonate plastic that is tough and doesn’t break or crack easily. The Dewalt toolset as well has a removable accessory case that facilitates portability. When it comes to the capacity, the Stanley tool set has a slight edge, holding 210 pieces of tools compared to Dewalt’s 168 pieces.

DeWalt DWMT73803 Mechanics Tool Kit Set

DeWalt DWMT73803 Mechanics Tool Kit Set

CHECK IT OUT

All the items in the Stanley tool set are chrome vanadium forged ensuring strength, durability, and suitability to high torque applications. Dewalt’s set of ratchets have a quick release system that allows easy and efficient ratcheting. Also, the bit drivers have anti-slip comfort padding, which ensures sure grips.

Just to be clear the Stanley tools also have excellently made bi-material handles that give comfort and control. Direct torque technology in the Dewalt sockets and wrenches give better grip and prevent rounding of fasteners. Dewalt also has a low profile directional lever that facilitates one hand operation. It is seemingly a closely fought battle between the two toolsets, but the Dewalt tool set seems to take the lead though narrowly.

Stanley vs dewalt drill

DEWALT DC725K-2 18 Volt Hammer Drill

DEWALT DC725K-2 18 Volt Hammer Drill

CHECK IT OUT

To start with brushless hammer drills are designed to allow ease of use and weight is a determining factor of ease of use. DEWALT DC725K-2 weighs 4.9 lbs while the Stanley 18V Brushless Drill weighs 3.5 lbs, making the Stanley 18V Brushless Drill the one that generates less fatigue. The both of the drills have two batteries capacity that ensures optimum runtime. Also, they have the same voltage and amperage rating. Looking at the impacts per minute, they go ahead to tie at 29,000 BPM. The DEWALT DC725K-2 eliminates bit slippage through the utilization of a single sleeve ratcheting chuck.

Stanley 18V Brushless Drill

Stanley 18V Brushless Drill

And on the other hand, the Stanley 18V Brushless Drill has a twin sleeve clutch collar that also holds the bit tightly eliminating the need to set the clutch during operation. The two drills offer versatility via the availability of 2-speed motors facilitating optimal performance. Upon purchasing any of the two tools, you get the freedom to claim your warranty through registration.

Putting all of these features under a beam balance, they make for perfect equilibrium and this Stanley vs Dewalt tool domineering ends in a tie.

Click to know more about
Top 5 Best Cordless Power Drill On The Market

Stanley vs dewalt tape measure

DEWALT DWHT33373L Short Tape

DEWALT DWHT33373L Short Tape

CHECK IT OUT

Looking at the market statistics, there is a clear indication that the Stanley 33-725 is more acclaimed compared to the DeWalt DWHT33373L tape measure. The job here is to find why? Foot stand out offer increased user reach, and the DeWalt DWHT33373L tape measure has 10 foot of stand out while the Stanley 33-725 has 11 foot. Mylar blade coating enhances the blade life for the Dewalt vs. Stanley’s Mylar polyester film that achieves the same purpose, and Blade Armor coating reinforcement for the first 6 foot that enhances durability.

Stanley Feet FatMax Tape Measure

Stanley Feet FatMax Tape Measure

CHECK IT OUT

Both tapes provide ease of use through the incorporation of construction material hook grabs and blade lock systems, but it is the Stanley that has a preheated spring that sees to it for smooth blade recoil. Both tapes have center marking that makes it easy to do framing work. Among the two Dewalt has the sturdiest of construction.

It is evident that the Dewalt tape is of much more superior construction, and Stanley’s less sturdy construction, but same functionality and is much more affordable. Apparently, the Stanley has a much bigger following due to its affordability and excellent functionality. Stanley or Dewalt, I will leave that to you.
Conclusion

In conclusion the only factor that settles the Stanley vs Dewalt battle is their marketing policies. Dewalt seems to believe in the policy of making quality products without having to compromise for the sake of cost. On the other hand, Stanley seems to compromise a little on quality, but in return, they make their products more affordable. At that point, I would hand over to you to decide on what that you want as you look towards making a purchase.

I am Caio Resende, Welcome to Power Tool Lab! It is a blog dedicated to all polular power tool and accessories including new, best for sale, expert reviews and guides. Whether you are a DIYer, Hobbyist, or professional contractors such as electricians and plumbers, I will provide you all the latest news and professional reviews for all your favorite tools and Brands. Our mission provides great perspective from many different end users.

3 Comments

  1. This review is so biased I can’t help but wonder if it was sponsored by DeWalt.

    The tape measure descriptions are incomplete but still somehow you’re able to make a conclusion about which one has the best build quality. Do you own both?

    You say the two drills end in a tie? Did you even consider that the Stanley is brushless and has a lithium ion battery? Of Course you wouldn’t because then your DeWalt would lose.

    We appreciate your effort in writing the review but please do proper comparisons with facts and real life tests.

    1. Hi, Thank you for your comment, Yeah, freedom of speech! If you have any tests and reviews about Stanley vs dewalt, please leave them on here, that’s very welcome.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.